Sign in or 

|
Sorsa |
100. RE: Why is Sigourney Weaver smoking in Avatar?
Jan 13 2010, 2:40 PM EST
| Post edited: Jan 13 2010, 2:42 PM EST
"Anyway... "What have you people been smoking out there?" It's just a goddamn movie. <-- Coolest reply, ever. Now Sorsa, translate that to Na'vi lang please."[Off-Topic] @Zahelu Thanks mate! I just threw that post as half joke. I before kept people speaking klingon and stuff likethat little bit overdoing fans, but i understand now how it feels to be real fan of movie. I'll try to learn it when i got free time, luckily i dont have ANY foreign languages in school period. You know how great it is to learn multiple languages same time? ;) Somehow i find Na'vi bit more easy than swedish somehow. Particularly on grammar, but words are pain for my. Especially pronouncing when i have to learn through english. [/Off-Topic] As i said earlier, we can't ban tobacco from movies if we don't ban the whole thing. It would be incoherent and that's one of the most important guideline what people should follow. There are drugs for example in movies, but that isn't causing thunderstorm? It is everyones choice. Many of my friends smoke and i've seen my grandfather smoking since i first saw him. Ok, he is in bad condition because of that and no wonder. Even my neughbour smokes. Yes, i see smoking a lot, but that just strengthens my negativity towards tobacco. Yes, i don't smoke and i will not start to. More i see it, more it disgusts me . Tobacco should be put away from sight for example in stores etc. but not in movies. Movies are art, storys about life etc. You cannot ban it from there as long as it is legal. I understand your concern about tobacco, but it isn't that simply alltimes in our world. Do you find this valuable? |
|
scrippsgirl |
101. RE: Why is Sigourney Weaver smoking in Avatar?
Jan 13 2010, 3:19 PM EST
"[Off-Topic] @ZaheluPeople start smoking as kids. Nicotine is highly addictive, and once kids start, they lose the "choice". Many are hooked until they die. Kids need protection from tobacco ads. Read the posts. There is a move to give an R rating to movies that show smoking, especially not showing consequences. Smoking in the movies is not "art", it's advertising. Smoking KILLS over 400,000 a year in the U.S. That isn't important? 0 out of 1 found this valuable. Do you? |
|
Sorsa |
102. RE: Why is Sigourney Weaver smoking in Avatar?
Jan 13 2010, 4:35 PM EST
Read my text again. I didn't say tobacco is art or anything similar. Is it always ad if some random guy walks down road while smoking?
1
out of
1 found this valuable.
Do you?
|
|
scrippsgirl |
103. RE: Why is Sigourney Weaver smoking in Avatar?
Jan 13 2010, 5:21 PM EST
"Read my text again. I didn't say tobacco is art or anything similar. Is it always ad if some random guy walks down road while smoking?"What I said was, product placement of tobacco in movies is not art. It's advertising. That is a well-researched and established fact. Tobacco is never placed randomly in films. It's always placed for maximum beneficial exposure. They want a good product from the film industry for their money. Smoking in movies does NOT reflect reality. In the real world, smokers tend to be poor and less educated. In movies, it's the powerful and successful who smoke the most. http://www.nci.nih.gov/newscenter/Tobaccomovies to get some facts. 1 out of 1 found this valuable. Do you? |
|
grinna |
104. RE: Why is Sigourney Weaver smoking in Avatar?
Jan 13 2010, 6:04 PM EST
" "It is interesting to see or read people's view regarding violence in a movie, as some type of defence to the placement of a smoking scene into a movie......this idea doesn't really flow along the same river really. Movies educate all ages of people. The good guy wins, the bad guy walks off in disgrace or dies etc etc. Movies have helped win wars on our stupid and sorry planet. Avatar did successfully typify the hard-line, lack of value base, money-mad corporation and the governments that they also run, and their pillage and theft of resources through self sanctified colonization of "anothers' " resources......in this type of movie genre, I think Avatar and Cameron won in their attempt at portraying this "good versus evil war" (of two worlds). Wars are typically violent; and educating audiences about how violence begins and ends is of some consequential importance (and is good education)....and if it is too gruesome, then the rating's committees step in and ajudicate - as others on this forum have correctly suggested. So where does smoking fit into this jigsaw of movie education? It showed Augustine's need to rellieve her stress by smoking, it also showed that this middle-aged executive can exude her gutsy powers, and can order others around in the best way, through puffing a smoke in her mouth.... As a marketer, I think this movie scene is directed through its force, not at the kids, but at their foollish already smoking, mums and dads......it gave them more fodder to fool themselves that smoking helps them gain power and position.....this one ironical and unethical moment, through a Director putting this smoking scene into operation, 'nicotine-stained' any ethical value-based positions that the movie had previously created ...just like a waiter serving up a beautiful bowl of soup, but as he places the bowl down in front of you, a piece of snot from his nose drops into your soup. 1 out of 1 found this valuable. Do you? |
|
FilmEcon101 |
105. RE: Why is Sigourney Weaver smoking in Avatar?
Jan 13 2010, 6:25 PM EST
Who is Avatar intended for? Well, besides fans like us, how about the little kids who can get McDonald's Avatar figures with their Happy Meals — worldwide. I'm sure they're psychoanlayzing Dr. Grace "Who has my goddamn cigarette?" Augustine... McDonald's and (probably) Twentieth Century-Fox have been working on this campaign for 18 months. Cross-promotion is designed to promote McDonald;s AND Avatar. So McDonald's is promoting to children as young as 6 or 7 a kid-rated movie with smoking in it. Yikes. (And before we go off on another tangent, tobacco kills more Americans than obesity. Nobody is proposing to R-rate cheeseburgers, etc. Everybody, even in Hollywood, knows tobacco is a special case, with ads banned from TV and radio, etc. There's an eight decade history of collaboration between film and tobacco companies.) See http://www.aboutmcdonalds.com/mcd/media_center/press_kits/Avatar.html 3 out of 3 found this valuable. Do you? |
|
NeoGriffin |
106. RE: Why is Sigourney Weaver smoking in Avatar?
Jan 13 2010, 7:20 PM EST
Sadly u need sponsors to make a movie, sadly money does make the world go round,stop focusing on the negative guys, just enjoy the movie and share the happy feelings 1 out of 2 found this valuable. Do you? |
|
grinna |
107. RE: Why is Sigourney Weaver smoking in Avatar?
Jan 13 2010, 7:55 PM EST
"Sadly u need sponsors to make a movie, sadly money does make the world go round, I said in my previous post, "just like a waiter serving up a beautiful bowl of soup, but as he places the bowl down in front of you, a piece of snot from his nose drops into your soup."....... NeoGriffin: Are you saying you would eat the boogy and not protest and send the soup back. 1 out of 1 found this valuable. Do you? |
|
Lax_Mofo |
108. RE: Why is Sigourney Weaver smoking in Avatar?
Jan 13 2010, 8:24 PM EST
"The problem is that smoking is never portrayed negatively. When is the last time you saw someone hack and cough and spit in the morning while getting that nicotine fix, hacking after any exertion,or walking around with an oxygen tank and still smoking? How about the people protesting the second hand smoke not being seen as party poopers? Or seeing much of any smoke? Showing NO consequences of smoking at all?the point i was trying to make is that stop blaming all of the smoking in movies. if parents were to stop blaming other things for the reasons kids do stuff like smoking, we would get farther. i mean yeah it has some influence, but ultimatly its the parents that have the most influence over kids. i mean come on, i remember when a teenager. yeah i saw smoking in movies but i KNEW that there is no way in hell i would be smoking. that is becuase my parents made it off limits. also when you complai9n about things for the reason your kid is bad, all your really doing is teaching your kikd to complain instead of get thigns done. 1 out of 2 found this valuable. Do you? |
|
FilmEcon101 |
109. RE: Why is Sigourney Weaver smoking in Avatar?
Jan 13 2010, 9:58 PM EST
I know how you feel, Mr. Mofo. And I'm glad to see your screen name gives parenting a big hug and a kiss! They need it!But the research says different: on tobacco, the movies undercut parents. Whether parents are strict or lax, smoking or non-smoking, exposure to on-screen smoking trumps parental influence. It's the single biggest influence on kids' starting to smoke. And these studies are finding what the tobacco companies have known all along: movies sell smoking. That's why. over the years, the tobacco companies put millions into product placement, cross-promotion, etc. They're very smart marketers working for very demanding management. That doesn't mean parents can't do a lot — like keep younger teens from watching R-rated films, 80% of which have smoking and at twice the incidence of PG-13 films, on average. But as long as kid-rated films push smoking, parents have got a stiff headwind. 1 out of 1 found this valuable. Do you? |
|
Lax_Mofo |
110. RE: Why is Sigourney Weaver smoking in Avatar?
Jan 13 2010, 11:12 PM EST
" And I'm glad to see your screen name gives parenting a big hug and a kiss! They need it!sarcasm is the worlds biggest downfall=] 0 out of 1 found this valuable. Do you? |
|
scrippsgirl |
111. RE: Why is Sigourney Weaver smoking in Avatar?
Jan 13 2010, 11:18 PM EST
"sarcasm is the worlds biggest downfall=]"Intentional ignorance is way ahead of sarcasm. Especially with all the learning tools right at your fingertips BTW, where did you get all your parenting data? It's wrong. Do you find this valuable? |
|
Lax_Mofo |
112. RE: Why is Sigourney Weaver smoking in Avatar?
Jan 13 2010, 11:29 PM EST
| Post edited: Jan 13 2010, 11:31 PM EST
"Intentional ignorance is way ahead of sarcasm. Especially with all the learning tools right at your fingertips BTW, where did you get all your parenting data? It's wrong."sigh, i forgot i was in a discussion with a bunch of grammar Nazi's. basically, stop complaining about a damn cigarette, people are getting so soft and touchy feely that common sense has gone through the window. you guys are always trying to find complicated answers to things, and your really wasting the effort. people are gonna do whatever they want to do regardless of a damn cigarette in a great film. hell i asked my neice about the cigarette and her thoughts ion it, and she said she was say to into the story to even think about it. stop trying to make everything so picture perfect(although might i add Jc has done a fantastic job at doing that) continued... 0 out of 1 found this valuable. Do you? |
|
Lax_Mofo |
113. RE: Why is Sigourney Weaver smoking in Avatar?
Jan 13 2010, 11:35 PM EST
and i also want to say that totally hiding our kids from tobacco is definatly not working in terms of making them not use it. im not trying to say that we should let our kids experiment. but come on, there are countless commercials about the risks of smoking tobacco, hell they even say on the damn box that smoking causes cancer. but to shun tobacco from our kids is the wrong way to do it. when you dont educate kids about it it creates curiosity, which in other words leads kids into trying it. if you want kids to stop smoking fully educate them about it, dont just hid it from them. what kid doesnt want to do things because there parent didnt want them to, give them the facts.
Do you find this valuable?
|
|
grinna |
114. RE: Why is Sigourney Weaver smoking in Avatar?
Jan 14 2010, 2:40 AM EST
"and i also want to say that totally hiding our kids from tobacco is definatly not working in terms of making them not use it. im not trying to say that we should let our kids experiment. but come on, there are countless commercials about the risks of smoking tobacco, hell they even say on the damn box that smoking causes cancer. but to shun tobacco from our kids is the wrong way to do it. when you dont educate kids about it it creates curiosity, which in other words leads kids into trying it. if you want kids to stop smoking fully educate them about it, dont just hid it from them. what kid doesnt want to do things because there parent didnt want them to, give them the facts."My great dad educated me LaxMofo, he caught me smoking once, consequently, he then told me to go down the street and buy ten cigars; at the age of about 14yrs. i walked down to the local Milkbar and purchased ten cigars in a packet.....cigarettes were able to be purchased by everyone and all back in those times (about 1966 in Australia).......dad said, "smoke these ten cigars son, and I will let you smoke for the rest of your life...." he then stipulated the rules as I began his challenge.....he insisted I do the drawback on the first cigar.......at the end of the first cigar my face was blue, and I spent the rest of that day sitting on the shower floor, with water trickling on my head, trying to get my breath back and trying to cool the heat in my chest.....I never, ever smoked again............... 1 out of 2 found this valuable. Do you? |
|
Sorsa |
115. RE: Why is Sigourney Weaver smoking in Avatar?
Jan 14 2010, 9:47 AM EST
When i eyed down whole page i noticed this thread seems to be fallen into almost flaming.Spelling correctly is nice, but i don't care about errors as long it is understandable. My enlish isn't also perfect, sorry about that. Oh c'mon get real guys! I'm out of this thread until level of discussion gets better. Peace! Do you find this valuable? |
|
dyer313 |
116. RE: Why is Sigourney Weaver smoking in Avatar?
Jan 14 2010, 10:21 AM EST
I have not read the previous part to this thread so sorry if i am not answering this straight.I smok(ed) for the last few years - since I was 15 and it sure as hell wasn't a film that started me off. I think that it was just part of her character people smoke. It is a terrible thing and I think I have stopped (i wont say i have stopped till it has been at the very least a year) and I hope that it dies out soon but I think this is being blown slightly out of proportion? just my 2 cents 0 out of 1 found this valuable. Do you? |
|
scrippsgirl |
117. RE: Why is Sigourney Weaver smoking in Avatar?
Jan 14 2010, 10:37 AM EST
"and i also want to say that totally hiding our kids from tobacco is definatly not working in terms of making them not use it. im not trying to say that we should let our kids experiment. but come on, there are countless commercials about the risks of smoking tobacco, hell they even say on the damn box that smoking causes cancer. but to shun tobacco from our kids is the wrong way to do it. when you dont educate kids about it it creates curiosity, which in other words leads kids into trying it. if you want kids to stop smoking fully educate them about it, dont just hid it from them. what kid doesnt want to do things because there parent didnt want them to, give them the facts."It's not "hiding" cigarettes to not have the main character showing smoking as cool. There are far fewer tobacco prevention ads than there are tobacco promotion strategies. Touchy-feely has nothing to do with it. Cigarette smoking is a huge public health problem. Are you not getting it that almost half a million people die every year? A vital part of education includes learning it yourself and then showing your kids how they are targeted by the tobacco industry. We've been trying to tell you, but you apparently don't want to hear. Experimentation is also what creates a smoker. Nicotine is highly addictivel Do you find this valuable? |
|
scrippsgirl |
118. RE: Why is Sigourney Weaver smoking in Avatar?
Jan 14 2010, 10:45 AM EST
"My great dad educated me LaxMofo, he caught me smoking once, consequently, he then told me to go down the street and buy ten cigars; at the age of about 14yrs. i walked down to the local Milkbar and purchased ten cigars in a packet.....cigarettes were able to be purchased by everyone and all back in those times (about 1966 in Australia).......dad said, "smoke these ten cigars son, and I will let you smoke for the rest of your life...." he then stipulated the rules as I began his challenge.....he insisted I do the drawback on the first cigar.......at the end of the first cigar my face was blue, and I spent the rest of that day sitting on the shower floor, with water trickling on my head, trying to get my breath back and trying to cool the heat in my chest.....I never, ever smoked again...............I'm glad the aversion therapy worked for you. I'm also glad the amount of nicotine you ingested didn't kill you. I'm wondering why people in this thread, despite all of the research and information that shows the effect on kids of smoking in films, why you still insist on thinking it doesn't. BTW, kids don't even know they're being targeted. It's up to the parents to let them know. Smoking is a pediatric disease and a huge public health issue. Would you get into an airplane if you knew that half a million people died in plane crashes every year? What would you say about flying? 1 out of 1 found this valuable. Do you? |
|
Lax_Mofo |
119. RE: Why is Sigourney Weaver smoking in Avatar?
Jan 14 2010, 8:46 PM EST
" Would you get into an airplane if you knew that half a million people died in plane crashes every year? What would you say about flying?"idk, probably that everything has its risks... Do you find this valuable? |
|
scrippsgirl |
120. RE: Why is Sigourney Weaver smoking in Avatar?
Jan 14 2010, 9:44 PM EST
"idk, probably that everything has its risks..."Would you fly, though, if you knew that one thousand people a day were killed in aircraft accidents? Have you taken a look at any of the facts about advertising to kids and smoking? If you are truly interested, go to http://www.smokefreemovies.ucsf.edu/ Do you find this valuable? |
|
Lax_Mofo |
121. RE: Why is Sigourney Weaver smoking in Avatar?
Jan 16 2010, 9:08 PM EST
"Would you fly, though, if you knew that one thousand people a day were killed in aircraft accidents? Have you taken a look at any of the facts about advertising to kids and smoking? If you are truly interested, go to http://www.smokefreemovies.ucsf.edu/"probably not, but you cant honestly say that someone doesnt know the risks of smoking. my friend is a kinder garden teacher and their teaching about how bad it is 0 out of 1 found this valuable. Do you? |
|
TomCScally |
122. RE: Why is Sigourney Weaver smoking in Avatar?
Jan 22 2010, 12:39 PM EST
| Post edited: Jan 22 2010, 12:58 PM EST
"Did James Cameron accept money from the tobacco industry in order to have Sigourney Weaver smoke in his movie? It is pathetic to see gratuitous smoking in movies. I am disappointed in James and Sigourney. This has got to stop."First impression you will get of Avatar is shock and horror as Weaver demanded a cigarette, I thought here we go again a loop hole where the tobacco industry will benefit from this pathetic Avatar smoking scene, (they even managed to make the smoke 3D), no doubt as we see in other Films that cast Weaver such as Alien, this is for sure a big plug to make smoking look cool and keep the tobacco industry in business. The other theme to Avatar is the fact that the video games slant of the film will also ensure its success, interesting how eco friendly that would be. Overall, I found Avatar a real fantasy, the Real D 3D effects is amazing, lets hope in future film makers take on board this issue of smoking. It really can make a difference to setting the mood of any film. 2 out of 2 found this valuable. Do you? |
|
scrippsgirl |
123. RE: Why is Sigourney Weaver smoking in Avatar?
Jan 22 2010, 1:04 PM EST
"probably not, but you cant honestly say that someone doesnt know the risks of smoking. my friend is a kinder garden teacher and their teaching about how bad it is"Of course people know the risks of smoking. Adults are aware, and kids not so much. Particularly risk-taking and low income kids. That's why Big Tobacco has a 12 million dollar a day budget for advertising, and more that they don't report. They aggressively pursue kids to replace the adult smokers who quit or die. This isn't a matter of passing stories around. A lot of research has been done on this subject. You can click on any of the links I've provided. Remember, not so long ago, the CEOs of the major tobacco companies swore in front of congress that nicotine was not addictive. 2 out of 2 found this valuable. Do you? |
|
ufischer |
124. RE: Why is Sigourney Weaver smoking in Avatar?
Apr 18 2010, 2:55 PM EDT
It is entirely incredible that so far in the future anyone will still voluntarily smoke... especially in an environment where breathing needs to be assisted with facemasks. The only reason for S.G. to smoke in that otherwise excellent movie was to promote smoking among teens. Us older folks have heard enough of the history of Big Tobacco in all forms of entertainment to be immune to this blatant payola. It is past time to outlaw all forms of advertising for products such as tobacco where there are zero health benefits and huge health issues. Meanwhile, I would suggest a campaign to boycott movies which feature gratuitous smoking. Villains who are destined to be killed in the first reel... ok, let 'em smoke... but characters with whom we are meant to identify... they should absolutely not be seen smoking on screen regardless of whether or not the actor is a smoker.On the other foot... I don't advocate banning tobacco or any other drug. I would hate to have tobacco added to the list of products whose sale finances armed gangs shooting it out in the streets. All the evidence points to the abject failure of the "war on drugs". Education and social pressure have been hugely successful in reducing smoking in North America and a similar approach to all other "recreational" drugs would doubtless be just as effective. Do you find this valuable? |
|
FLOORMANPHIL |
125. RE: Why is Sigourney Weaver smoking in Avatar?
Apr 22 2010, 3:27 PM EDT
IS SMOKING ILLEGAL---NO! SO WHY CANT PEOPLE USE A LEGAL ITEM ON MOVIES OR WHATEVER--MAKE IT ILLEGAL OR SHUT THE HELL UP!!! RIGHT KNOW ITS LEGAL , SO SHUT THE F..K UP
0
out of
1 found this valuable.
Do you?
|
|
FilmEcon101 |
126. RE: Why is Sigourney Weaver smoking in Avatar?
Apr 22 2010, 4:53 PM EDT
"IS SMOKING ILLEGAL---NO! SO WHY CANT PEOPLE USE A LEGAL ITEM ON MOVIES OR WHATEVER--MAKE IT ILLEGAL OR SHUT THE HELL UP!!! RIGHT KNOW ITS LEGAL , SO SHUT THE F..K UP"Shut the what up? I'm sorry, I don't think I followed that last subtle turn in your argument. The question is not whether tobacco is legal. The question is whether the U.S. film industry, which has a long history of playing footsie with the tobacco industry, should keep hooking kids and bolstering the tobacco giants' bottom line. The solution is to R-rate future films with smoking, because studios routinely tune films to achieve ratings that suit their marketing plans. If they want a PG-13, they would leave the smoking out, just as they now reserve (legal) language like yours for so-called "mature" films. And any filmmaker who thinks smoking is essential could throw it on screen at any time — and take the "R" just as if he used two F-bombs. If a Universal theme park ride sent one child home in a coma, it would be shut down. But when a Universal film rated for kids features tobacco imagery proven to recruit hundreds of thousands of kids to smoke, then it's all about art? Before you hit the CAPS LOCK key next time, check out the tobacco documents on smokefreemovies.ucsf.edu. Corporations gone wild! . Do you find this valuable? |
|
labelaudition |
127. RE: Why is Sigourney Weaver smoking in Avatar?
Apr 25 2010, 10:13 PM EDT
It's not because anybody is a ***** because they're against Sigourney smoking in a movie, it's that it's such a lame and obvious big tobacco payoff to infiltrate young people's general feelings about cigarettes and smoking. Sigourney comes out of the pod and demands a cigarette when they could have easily had her ask for a latte, backrub, pepsi, redbull, lipgloss, diaper, excederin, laptop, towel, toothbrush, comb, oreo cookie or a sports score back on earth. If you're addicted to smoking, chances are you're also dumb enough to think it's a personal freedom and defend it's badness by putting down non-smokers who don't want their family members to die 20, 30 or 40 years too early. James Cameron and Sigourney Weaver are whores and that's that. End of story. Stupid greedy move which probably cost the film an Oscar through karma. Ponder this, why is the military bad guy in awesome shape, does not smoke and the good caring scientist a smoker? What does that say when well educated good guys are the smokers in films? It sends a mixed signal to kids. And James Cameron is responsible since he knows everyone on the planet was going to watch this movie and as a huge director must have known the criticism he would receive putting that part into the film.
Do you find this valuable?
|
|
jchilliard |
128. RE: Why is Sigourney Weaver smoking in Avatar?
Apr 26 2010, 10:39 AM EDT
I agree with labelaudition. What was the point of smoking in Avatar? It was a product placement in order to influence children. It was a sad sell out by Cameron and Weaver for money. If powerful and rich people such as Cameron and Weaver are willing to take money that will lead to bitter illness, what does that say about us all? Do we all just take the money and the fun and then forget about it? Where is the remorse on their part? Or on our part? What does this say about who they really are? Do we want to hear from them again? Or, if they produce another important movie, do we patronize them again? Are we just as pathetic? Can we all ever become something more than animals? Could Cameron and Weaver ever have the guts to try to lead us to the better part of ourselves? Cameron makes a movie appearing to be sensitive to the environment, but it appears it all is opportunism on his part. He uses "green" themes which we find alluring, and then desecrates them with this. We are influenced by others. The smoking in Avatar is meant to influence us to smoke. Delivered in the Trojan Horse of a "green movie". How do we help ourselves out of our condition? 1 out of 2 found this valuable. Do you? |
|
ufischer |
129. RE: Why is Sigourney Weaver smoking in Avatar?
Apr 26 2010, 1:22 PM EDT
Rather than a general boycott of Sigourney and Cameron, a better, more likely to produce the desired result (no more sympathetic characters appealing to children to start smoking) approach would be to start a loud public campaign to boycott any movies where a protagonist role-model type character is shown smoking. Let the product placement involve villains who have to be killed horribly (or die of emphysema :) ) in the first reel..... (hmmm. I guess they don't have reels anymore.... ok in the first hour or so....)1 out of 1 found this valuable. Do you? |
|
ufischer |
130. RE: Why is Sigourney Weaver smoking in Avatar?
Apr 26 2010, 1:26 PM EDT
If Cameron had a role in this movie maybe it would have been as the corporate wonk who reluctantly agreed to the main villain's plan to bomb the crap out of the "savages".... but he wouldn't be shown smoking... not attractive enough to the kids. :)
1
out of
1 found this valuable.
Do you?
|
|
TallLakota |
131. RE: Why is Sigourney Weaver smoking in Avatar?
Apr 26 2010, 2:31 PM EDT
"I don't think it had anything to do with the tobacco industry. There was exactly one cigarette smoked in the entire movie. I believe it was done as part of the introduction to her character. There's likely no smoking allowed in the science labs, and especially not in the.. uh, linking chambers? (I've only seen it once, forgive me.) But Grace Augustine gets Whatever the Hell She Wants Whenever the Hell She Wants it! She was the most respected and feared non-military person on the base. She deserves a smoke for that."One thing I liked about Avatar was its Authentic Script. Grace asking for a Cigarette after going off line from her Avatar made that scene more realistic. It is interesting to see no one complaining about all the profanity that was in Avatar. Like the profanity, Grace asking for the cigarette made the dialog in the movie more realistic and made Avatar more Authentic. 0 out of 1 found this valuable. Do you? |
|
ufischer |
132. RE: Why is Sigourney Weaver smoking in Avatar?
Apr 26 2010, 4:20 PM EDT
Asking for a beer or some fictional futuristic sounding relaxing drug would have made the same point and been more "authentic" given the unlikelihood that restrictions on smoking in public will be relaxed in the future ... ESPECIALLY in an environment where breathing requires a facemask.... The military prick could have been made the "authentic" smoker if that was the point of the cigarette. The fact that the 2nd coolest character in the movie was portrayed as a smoker makes it a come-on for pre-teens to become smokers, Just as single cigarette sales and cute pink packaging are designed to lure pre-teens and young teens into a potentially deadly addiction. As for the profanity, given the trend with rap music, by the time the era in which the movie was set rolls around it is quite plausible that profanity will be even less of a big deal than it is now.
Do you find this valuable?
|
|
00r |
133. RE: Why is Sigourney Weaver smoking in Avatar?
Apr 26 2010, 4:37 PM EDT
"Did James Cameron accept money from the tobacco industry in order to have Sigourney Weaver smoke in his movie? It is pathetic to see gratuitous smoking in movies. I am disappointed in James and Sigourney. This has got to stop."it shows she was stressed.. if stupid kids start to smoke let them... its a CHOICE, its not saying HEY KIDS CHECK THIS OUT! DO THIS! its part of a movie. honestly, if you're dumb enough to have movies make decisions for you, THEN GOOD RIDDANCE. Darwinism at work. 1 out of 2 found this valuable. Do you? |
|
victoryblade |
134. RE: Why is Sigourney Weaver smoking in Avatar?
Apr 26 2010, 5:05 PM EDT
Why are so many people compaining over a damn cigarette? 00r is right, it's just a movie! Whoever is gullible enough to copy everything they see in a movie deserves to suffer the consequences! Don't blame the filmakers!
0
out of
1 found this valuable.
Do you?
|
|
FilmEcon101 |
135. RE: Why is Sigourney Weaver smoking in Avatar?
Apr 26 2010, 5:46 PM EDT
"Why are so many people compaining over a damn cigarette? 00r is right, it's just a movie! Whoever is gullible enough to copy everything they see in a movie deserves to suffer the consequences! Don't blame the filmakers!"Tobacco companies have been exploiting "just movies" since 1927. They were smart to do this, because movies sell smoking worldwide. When Jim Cameron gets back from saving the rainforest from a giant dam, he can give some thought to saving kids from the tobacco companies. Except, oh yeah, he's part of that problem. 0 out of 1 found this valuable. Do you? |
|
scrippsgirl |
136. RE: Why is Sigourney Weaver smoking in Avatar?
Apr 26 2010, 7:15 PM EDT
"Why are so many people compaining over a damn cigarette? 00r is right, it's just a movie! Whoever is gullible enough to copy everything they see in a movie deserves to suffer the consequences! Don't blame the filmakers!"The tobacco industry and the film makers have been counting on the American public being too ignorant to see or be aware of the way tobacco is advertised. In addition to promotions in films like this and other marketing, the tobacco industry spends at least $12,000,000.00 per DAY to advertise its product, especially to kids. Why? Because if they didn't make their product look glamorous, daring, and a little forbidden, nobody would smoke. Public health has a tiny budget compared to that of tobacco giants. The result? Ignorant tobacco apologists blaming the victims when facts are pointed out. Parents are fighting an uphill battle. The film and tobacco industries are guilty as charged. Over 1,000 people a DAY in the U.S. alone die from smoking. Do you find this valuable? |
|
scrippsgirl |
137. RE: Why is Sigourney Weaver smoking in Avatar?
Apr 26 2010, 7:23 PM EDT
"One thing I liked about Avatar was its Authentic Script. Grace asking for a Cigarette after going off line from her Avatar made that scene more realistic. It is interesting to see no one complaining about all the profanity that was in Avatar. Like the profanity, Grace asking for the cigarette made the dialog in the movie more realistic and made Avatar more Authentic."Authentic script? Realistic? Why would smoking make the scene more realistic? It's in a scientific facility, and nobody else smokes. How real is that? If profanity killed over 400,000 people in the U.S. every year, you bet it would be banned. That is, unless some giant industry found a way to profit from swearing. Do you find this valuable? |
|
victoryblade |
138. RE: Why is Sigourney Weaver smoking in Avatar?
Apr 26 2010, 10:10 PM EDT
This argument is pointless. I don't smoke, and I've seen plenty of movies that display smoking. Are you people going to blame murder and other crimes on films too? If you really want to make a difference in the war against tobacco, you should make these posts on some anti-smoking campaign site. Or better yet, try to help other people you know who actually smoke to quit. Stop bringing your anger out on this thread that was just recently revived after a three month gap.
Do you find this valuable?
|
|
TallLakota |
139. RE: Why is Sigourney Weaver smoking in Avatar?
Apr 26 2010, 10:36 PM EDT
| Post edited: Apr 26 2010, 10:40 PM EDT
"Asking for a beer or some fictional futuristic sounding relaxing drug would have made the same point and been more "authentic" given the unlikelihood that restrictions on smoking in public will be relaxed in the future ... ESPECIALLY in an environment where breathing requires a facemask.... The military prick could have been made the "authentic" smoker if that was the point of the cigarette. The fact that the 2nd coolest character in the movie was portrayed as a smoker makes it a come-on for pre-teens to become smokers, Just as single cigarette sales and cute pink packaging are designed to lure pre-teens and young teens into a potentially deadly addiction. As for the profanity, given the trend with rap music, by the time the era in which the movie was set rolls around it is quite plausible that profanity will be even less of a big deal than it is now. "A Cigarette is still a common item. Asking for an exotic futuristic item would have cheapened that scene and the movie. When I saw her asking for a "Cigarette" none of those add-ons crossed my mind such as "its payola" or it will encourge teens to smoke. Sorry, my mind does not work that way, and maybe that is why I enjoyed Avatar so much. Do you find this valuable? |
|
scrippsgirl |
140. RE: Why is Sigourney Weaver smoking in Avatar?
Apr 27 2010, 12:28 AM EDT
That's the reaction the tobacco industry wants to hear. And you don't think that demanding a cigarette in a laboratory setting cheapened the portayal of a futuristic society? Please. Now you get some idea why it's so hard to get kids not to start smoking. Have you read any of the hundreds of articles available that scientifically demonstrate the effect of smoking in the film industry to kid's decisions to start smoking? Are you in denial, or a smoker in denial?
0
out of
1 found this valuable.
Do you?
|
|
scrippsgirl |
141. RE: Why is Sigourney Weaver smoking in Avatar?
Apr 27 2010, 12:29 AM EDT
BTW, there is a program in Native American cultures called "Keep Tobacco Sacred".
0
out of
1 found this valuable.
Do you?
|
|
scrippsgirl |
142. RE: Why is Sigourney Weaver smoking in Avatar?
Apr 27 2010, 12:35 AM EDT
It's called Prevention. It's much harder to quit than it is to start. I have friends that want to quit but can't. My mother died of complications of Emphysema. She tried many times to quit but couldn't. It's not anger, it's sometimes frustration at how people refuse to see how marketing is targeting our kids. Have you ever read any of the hundreds of resources positively linking kid's smoking to a lifelong exposure to the smoking of positive role models, showing no negative symptoms of smoking? Of the long and prosperous relationship between films and the tobacco industry? If you really are a non-smoker, good for you. Maybe you could help prevent a kid from starting by dropping the denial about tobacco marketing strategies.
0
out of
1 found this valuable.
Do you?
|
|
scrippsgirl |
143. RE: Why is Sigourney Weaver smoking in Avatar?
Apr 27 2010, 12:37 AM EDT
This thread is about the effects on kids of smoking in PG-13 movies. If you don't like or understand the implications of this type of marketing, I'm sure you can find another forum.
0
out of
1 found this valuable.
Do you?
|
|
TallLakota |
144. RE: Why is Sigourney Weaver smoking in Avatar?
Apr 27 2010, 1:54 PM EDT
"This thread is about the effects on kids of smoking in PG-13 movies. If you don't like or understand the implications of this type of marketing, I'm sure you can find another forum. "I don't smoke and I am aware of the heath issues centered around smoking. However, Negitive thinking and the automatic angary statements that goes with it, is not a good way to Talk or Walk. I do not encourge our young to smoke, or to encourge them to be Negitive. Being Negitive is more hazardious to ones heath than smoking. My mind does not automaticly seek things to get Angary about. Yes, there are plenty things that one can be upset about in life. I have done battle with many of those things as well. It did not involve ranting online. Just because I am not into your Negitivity does not mean that I should find another forum. I walk a good way called the "Good Red Road". That means I am a Warrior and have faced thougher problems than the one your ranting about here. However, I choose not be Negitive and find instant issues in things to be Angary about. That is just not my Way. Please Respect my Way. Do you find this valuable? |
|
TallLakota |
145. RE: Why is Sigourney Weaver smoking in Avatar?
Apr 27 2010, 2:28 PM EDT
| Post edited: Apr 27 2010, 2:33 PM EDT
"This thread is about the effects on kids of smoking in PG-13 movies. If you don't like or understand the implications of this type of marketing, I'm sure you can find another forum. "BTW...I cant think of a more Negative scene to present smoking than Grace demanding a cigarette after going off line. How can an cranky old lady just getting out bed demanding a cigarette, entice a young person to smoke?? A Jake would say.."What Was Your Thinking?". This sounds more like an anti-smoking clip. If the tobaco lobby wanted to place a clip, enticing one to smoke they would have chosen a much better scene and charactor. Or at least show Grace in a better mood puffing on a cigarette. Do you find this valuable? |
|
FilmEcon101 |
146. RE: Why is Sigourney Weaver smoking in Avatar?
Apr 27 2010, 3:06 PM EDT
"BTW...I cant think of a more Negative scene to present smoking than Grace demanding a cigarette after going off line. How can an cranky old lady just getting out bed demanding a cigarette, entice a young person to smoke?? A Jake would say.."What Was Your Thinking?". This sounds more like an anti-smoking clip.Her demand was an exercise of power. "I am the boss here and get anything I want — hop to it." But regardless, the research shows that it is the cumulative exposure to all kinds of tobacco imagery on screen that recruits kids to smoke. Bad guys who smoke actually have more influence than good guys who smoke, but there are more good guys who smoke, so the influence is about 50-50. Wild, but that's the way it works. Cigarette advertising always played it both ways: "You're a lone wolf who doesn't care what other people think. You're a popular party person, one of the crowd." Movie images of smoking also play both sides of the street. The real point is: smoking on screen validates and legitimate smoking. Showing powerful (you say cranky, but that's gender-typing) women smoking was a deliberate ploy on the part of tobacco companies to recruit more women smokers in the 1930s and 1940s. Ms. Weaver, never the demure violet, has smoked in most of her films. It's a long established "type." Joan Crawford, another such, made deals with five different cigarette companies during her own career. 0 out of 1 found this valuable. Do you? |
|
dyer313 |
147. RE: Why is Sigourney Weaver smoking in Avatar?
Apr 27 2010, 7:10 PM EDT
In my opinion at least in the UK the message has got through, when I was in my sisters class (16 yo) 4 years ago, about 35 of 45 students smoked, now there are only 3 smokers in her entire year, and they are entirely social smokers.Personally, I smoke, I enjoy it which is why I smoke, I stop immediately when the enjoyment fades. As hard as it is for many to understand I often go weeks, sometimes even months without even thinking about a cigarette, it isn't something I need just something I enjoy from time to time. However I don't think that this scene had anything to do with a smoking ad, merely a signal of power, I think it would have been the same with where is my "goddamn; cigarette; drink; lab report; jacket'' I don't think it matters what it was. To me it also signalled that to her, life in the Avatar was perhaps less stressful than life in the real world as it were. But then again that is more jake… anyway it is late here, i should go to sleep, at least it is something to ponder over :) Do you find this valuable? |
|
Darkah |
148. RE: Why is Sigourney Weaver smoking in Avatar?
Apr 27 2010, 7:26 PM EDT
The amount of smoking found in AVATAR is very minimal at best. After Grace asked for her cigarette, how many times was smoking portrayed? I can't even remember any. There wasn't enough smoking in AVATAR to have any significant effect on anyone. The way it was portrayed did not make it look cool. To me, when Grace immediately asked for her cigarette, it showed it to be an addictive habit someone needs to overcome a stressful situation. That's definitely a negative portrayal. What little time was spent on that is not worth all of this fuss being made. I can't believe that anyone was influenced to start smoking from what was portrayed on AVATAR. The greater messages overpowered any smoking "message" that some are trying to blow way out of proportion. Now, having said that, I was surprised to see it in the film, but it was so fleeting that I forgot about it right away. I by the way, am a reformed smoker. I smoked for 16 years and haven't smoked for almost 30 years now. Do you find this valuable? |
|
TallLakota |
149. RE: Why is Sigourney Weaver smoking in Avatar?
Apr 27 2010, 7:58 PM EDT
| Post edited: Apr 27 2010, 8:04 PM EDT
"The amount of smoking found in AVATAR is very minimal at best. After Grace asked for her cigarette, how many times was smoking portrayed? I can't even remember any. There wasn't enough smoking in AVATAR to have any significant effect on anyone. The way it was portrayed did not make it look cool. To me, when Grace immediately asked for her cigarette, it showed it to be an addictive habit someone needs to overcome a stressful situation. That's definitely a negative portrayal.You are Right, Darkah and dyer313. It not worth all the Fuss some in here are trying to make. If that scene was any kind of smoking message, it was an anti-smoking message. We will just let ones who want to make a Fuss make a Fuss. Prehaps they need a Cigarette to calm them selves. Do you find this valuable? |